Hi, I ran it and if you worked it out alone, then respect! I guess it could be hard to work out an entire, existing city. I really like the intro and the idea that a person walks through a city and looks at places, together with old photographs and some historic background through voiceovers.

Though, I sometimes had hard times to figure out what in the 3D scene matches with the stuff in the photo. Maybe, if the person would just walk into the same spot and look into the same direction as the original photographer, it could be easier, I suppose.

Here are some remarks:

- I wish there were (optional) subtitles
- In the corridor towards the curling club, there are two trees, against which the walking person collides, then it collides against a house - is this intended?
- Are the animated avatars indicating, that an old man / young boy is speaking? A real photograph would be way cooler to get to know these people smile
- There is a full screen video playing when you tell about the burning school (am I right?)... it causes the application to go into windowed mode, why don't you play it fullscreen? Or better: why don't you do it in real 3D? The photoring and the photo-standups are a great idea, why not making the school fade into a grey, historic version, let burn in 3D with particles and stuff and when the scene is over, all fire and smoke vanishes and the "today" building is reappearing again?
- you are sometimes telling about buildings and landmarks; it would be cool if you could draw some overlays for the stuff you are talking about
- I think some houses are floating?

Other than that a nice project and I wish you the very best!

Last edited by HeelX; 01/30/12 14:00.