Just to throw a spanner in the works for both of you, heres my two cents worth.
(BTW I have faith in evolution, but I dont deny God, I just dont have enough proof yet)

Believers: If all the species of animals were saved on the ark during the
flood, how did the ones that lived over-seas get TO the ark, swim? And how
did they get back home? Treading water while the water was high would be easier.

Athiests: Evolution is very hit or miss dont you agree? So is any TOOL when
its weilder is not paying attention. But evolution would be a very useful
tool to an entity in the process of creating a man....