I liked the bottem better. Dunno, dark was better on my eyes. Other than that, they seemed pretty equal. Good job.

I like the dark one a little better. They are both about equal though.

second one I would better like to buy than the first one. But from details the first one is better.

In the dark shot if you concentrate on the cavewalls and the black cloud there the texture looks blurry. Maybe you can put a kids drawing filter over that or make it darker.

The first shot looks boring. Some years ago it could be good, or if the game would be named zelda. Maybe the pokemon kids fangroup would like it. Maybe you could put big goblin mechs on the market place destroing some market shops.

But the cave with that monster is defeneatly most interesting for me.

Hm, i actually do like both in some way. Usually i don't like it when covert art is ingame pictures. It should be higher detailed models or a nice high detailed drawn picture. But in this case it actually fits.

One thing that bothers me a little is the name. It feels like the axys name is to small. If you look at Zelda for example the name Zelda is bigger than "the windwaker" or "ocarina of time". It feels that if we have a hero with a specific name bring it forth In these pictures the "truthseeker battle against lies" dominates totally. But that's just me

Good job

I think the first one fits better because it fits to the style of the character.

Thus the colors are in a better averall combination.

why's the front guy squint-eyed? *g*

i like the first one better, fits the overall style most.